Oil and Gas News from OilGasDaily.Com  
OIL AND GAS
Fracking has less impact on groundwater than traditional oil and gas production
by Staff Writers
Tucson AZ (SPX) Aug 17, 2019

Oil and gas well with brine separator tank in background in southern Ontario, Canada.

Conventional oil and gas production methods can affect groundwater much more than fracking, according to hydrogeologists Jennifer McIntosh from the University of Arizona and Grant Ferguson from the University of Saskatchewan.

High-volume hydraulic fracturing, known as fracking, injects water, sand and chemicals under high pressure into petroleum-bearing rock formations to recover previously inaccessible oil and natural gas. This method led to the current shale gas boom that started about 15 years ago.

Conventional methods of oil and natural gas production, which have been in use since the late 1800s, also inject water underground to aid in the recovery of oil and natural gas.

"If we want to look at the environmental impacts of oil and gas production, we should look at the impacts of all oil and gas production activities, not just hydraulic fracturing," said McIntosh, a University of Arizona professor of hydrology and atmospheric sciences.

"The amount of water injected and produced for conventional oil and gas production exceeds that associated with fracking and unconventional oil and gas production by well over a factor of 10," she said.

McIntosh and Ferguson looked at how much water was and is being injected underground by petroleum industry activities, how those activities change pressures and water movement underground, and how those practices could contaminate groundwater supplies.

While groundwater use varies by region, about 30% of Canadians and more than 45% of Americans depend on the resource for their municipal, domestic and agricultural needs. In more arid regions of the United States and Canada, surface freshwater supplies are similarly important.

McIntosh and Ferguson found there is likely more water now in the petroleum-bearing formations than initially because of traditional production activities.

To push the oil and gas toward extraction wells, the conventional method, known as enhanced oil recovery, injects water into petroleum-bearing rock formations. Saline water is produced as a by-product and is then re-injected, along with additional freshwater, to extract more oil and gas.

However, at the end of the cycle, the excess salt water is disposed of by injecting it into depleted oil fields or deep into geological formations that don't contain oil and gas. That injection of waste water has changed the behavior of liquids underground and increases the likelihood of contaminated water reaching freshwater aquifers.

Some of the water injected as part of oil and gas production activities is freshwater from the surface or from shallow aquifers. McIntosh said that could affect groundwater and surface water supplies in water-stressed regions such as New Mexico or Texas.

"There's a critical need for long-term - years to decades - monitoring for potential contamination of drinking water resources not only from fracking, but also from conventional oil and gas production," McIntosh said.

The team published their paper, "Conventional Oil--The Forgotten Part of the Water-Energy Nexus," online June 30 in the journal Groundwater. Global Water Futures funded the research.

McIntosh has been involved in studies about the environmental impacts of hydraulic fracturing. She started wondering how those impacts compare to the impacts of the conventional methods of oil and gas production - methods that have been used for about 120 years and continue to be used.

Both fracking and conventional practices use groundwater and surface water when there isn't enough water from other sources to continue petroleum production.

To see how all types of oil and gas production activities affected water use in Canada and the U.S., she and Ferguson synthesized data from a variety of sources. The published scientific studies that were available covered only a few regions. Therefore, the scientists also delved into reports from state agencies and other sources of information.

The researchers found information for the Western Canada Sedimentary Basin, the Permian Basin (located in New Mexico and Texas), the states of Oklahoma, California and Ohio, and the total amount of water produced by high-volume hydraulic fracturing throughout the U.S.

"What was surprising was the amount of water that's being produced and re-injected by conventional oil and gas production compared to hydraulic fracturing," McIntosh said. "In most of the locations we looked at - California was the exception - there is more water now in the subsurface than before. There's a net gain of saline water."

There are regulations governing the petroleum industry with regard to groundwater, but information about what is happening underground varies by province and state. Some jurisdictions keep excellent data while for others it's virtually nonexistent. Despite this, Ferguson said he and McIntosh can make some observations.

"I think the general conclusions about water use and potential for contamination are correct, but the details are fuzzy in some areas," Ferguson said. "Alberta probably has better records than most areas, and the Alberta Energy Regulator has produced similar numbers to ours for that region. We saw similar trends for other oil and gas producing regions, but we need better reporting, record keeping and monitoring."

Oil and gas production activities can have environmental effects far from petroleum-producing regions. For example, previous studies show that operating disposal wells can cause detectable seismic activity more than 90 kilometers away. Conventional activities inject lower volumes of water and at lower pressure but take place over longer periods of time, which may cause contamination over greater distances.

Another wild card is the thousands of active, dormant and abandoned wells across North America. Some are leaky or were improperly decommissioned, providing possible pathways for contamination of freshwater aquifers.

While there is some effort to deal with this problem through organizations such as Alberta's Orphan Well Association, there is little consensus as to the size of the problem. Ferguson said depending on which source is cited, the decommissioning price tag ranges from a few billion to a few hundred billion dollars.

A 2017 report from Canada's C.D. Howe Institute indicates that there are 155,000 wells in Alberta yet to be remediated. A 2014 paper by other researchers suggest Pennsylvania alone has at least 300,000 abandoned wells, many of which are "lost" because there are no records of their existence nor is there surface evidence that an oil well was once there.

"We haven't done enough site investigations and monitoring of groundwater to know what the liability really looks like," Ferguson said. "My guess is that some wells probably should be left as is and others are going to need more work to address migration of brines and hydrocarbons from leaks that are decades old."

Research paper


Related Links
University of Arizona
All About Oil and Gas News at OilGasDaily.com


Thanks for being here;
We need your help. The SpaceDaily news network continues to grow but revenues have never been harder to maintain.

With the rise of Ad Blockers, and Facebook - our traditional revenue sources via quality network advertising continues to decline. And unlike so many other news sites, we don't have a paywall - with those annoying usernames and passwords.

Our news coverage takes time and effort to publish 365 days a year.

If you find our news sites informative and useful then please consider becoming a regular supporter or for now make a one off contribution.
SpaceDaily Contributor
$5 Billed Once


credit card or paypal
SpaceDaily Monthly Supporter
$5 Billed Monthly


paypal only


OIL AND GAS
Peru protesters set fire to building housing China oil firm
Lima (AFP) Aug 17, 2019
Protesters set fire to a building housing the offices of a Chinese oil company Friday, during a violent labor demonstration in northern Peru, the interior ministry said. The unrest occurred in El Alto after a meeting over better working conditions broke down between China National Petroleum Corp (CNPC), local authorities, and oil workers. "After that, mobs burned tires... while another group set fire to the facilities of Confipetrol, a company that provides services to China National Petroleum C ... read more

Comment using your Disqus, Facebook, Google or Twitter login.



Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

OIL AND GAS
Protein factors increasing yield of a biofuel precursor in microscopic algae

EU slaps anti-subsidy duties on Indonesian biodiesel

Supercomputing improves biomass fuel conversion

Novel catalysis approach reduces carbon dioxide to methane

OIL AND GAS
Mapping the energetic landscape of solar cells

WTO to set up panel to judge US-China solar panel dispute

Scientists discover key factors in how some algae harness solar energy

New design strategy brightens up the future of perovskite-based light-emitting diodes

OIL AND GAS
Growth of wind energy points to future challenges, promise

E.ON announces 440 MW southern Texas windfarm

Kenya launches Africa's biggest wind farm

Stanford study shows how to improve production at wind farms

OIL AND GAS
Framatome, Warsaw University of Technology to establish nuclear energy training and development programs

UN nuclear watchdog to have new chief in place by January

US renews waivers for Iran civil nuclear projects

Framatome deploys new tool for innovative inspection of baffle bolts in reactor vessels

OIL AND GAS
American media promotes false balance on climate science, research shows

Climate deniers get more media play than scientists: study

NASA gauges plant stress in Costa Rican drought

Climate battle will 'succeed or fail' in Asia: UN

OIL AND GAS
Uber shares skid as quarterly loss soars

Lyft gets boost from improving outlook

Lyft suspends e-bikes after battery fires

Five things to know about VW's 'dieselgate' scandal

OIL AND GAS
Explosions at Baghdad weapons depot blamed on Israel, U.S.

Foreign jihadists on death row out of Iraqi govt hands: PM

Iraq recovers over $1 bn in stolen state funds

Five years on, Yazidis remember brutal IS onslaught

OIL AND GAS
Iran to bypass uranium enrichment maximum despite calls for rethink

Mega-cloud from Canadian wildfires will help model impacts of nuclear war

France says 'needs no permission' for Iran dialogue after Trump swipe

North Korea says latest test was 'new weapon'







The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2026 - SpaceDaily. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.